I haven't forgotten about you, I promise. My "weekend" runs Tuesday / Wednesday on average and some weeks, I'm barely at home (literally this week as I stayed at a friends'). I continued to read and take notes so that today I could compose something to share with you.
While I'm trying to make this less a "review" and just an overview of my journey through Star Wars, it's in my nature to comment on things like story structure, character development, and grammar. I'm an author myself*, so I notice these things and am driven to point them out.
Also, on a final "house cleaning" note, I do apologize for the awkward structure of my posts. Blogging, to me, is somewhere between writing an article and writing a journal entry. I've been trying to find the right balance and if I'm not there yet, please bear with me.
My first point of order...
As I had feared over the years, the books do seem to expect a pre-existing knowledge of many, many things. While this may seem to make for smoother story telling, it can actually hurt new readers. Sure, someone who has read through Wookiepedia or most of the books is going to be fine. Someone who has just seen the movies, maybe played some of the games? Not so much.
Look at other book series. Each one, usually in the first chapter, will give a brief overview of what's going on. Who the main character is, major plot points, etc... and if something comes along that refers back to a previous book, we'll get a recap. Well, most series do this. They all should.
I already knew that Sith were also a species, but I had never looked into the background. The way this book reads, it's as if the origin of the Sith as a system of belief/practice was created by the Sith species, who interbred with ancient human houses to expand out. Instead, it's the other way around. The Dark Lords found the Sith, saw their use (being naturally Force Sensitive), and bred with them to create the people they wanted. They bred for emotion, health, skill, Force, etc... It makes much more sense that way, but it's not clear at all by how the book describes it.
I know this isn't the author's fault, but Sith-species and Sith-organization can lead to a lot of confusing passages.
This time, they did as told. He knew: Tie it to self-preservation, and a Sith would do anything. Even this bunch.
It is not clear whether it means Sith, the species, or Sith, the organization. In another section, the statement "every ensign an emperor" is applied to the Sith, as an explanation for how difficult it is to get them to obey orders. The first implies the species, the second -- as it references a naval role -- implies the organization. I do hope it means the species as if the organization is this difficult to deal with, then how did they rise to such power? We saw in the original trilogy how swiftly Vader would deal with dissent, but most people followed commands and orders very swiftly. In Precipice, Korsin is fighting his people at every turn. In fact, the author makes an effort to point out every non-Sith (species) or non-human character, explaining how they listen, aren't overly ambitious, or an ally to Korsin.
I can understand the concept that by the original trilogy, they've gotten rid of that behavior or bred it out, but at the same time... how did they rise as great as they did? How did they ever become any threat at all? If a captain is spending all of his time trying to appease egos and convince people to do what he asks, a starship can't run. Maybe further books will explain this, but right now I'm baffled...
I like Yaru Korsin, a lot. He's a really strong character and a good concept of what Sith is. I like when an evil character is charismatic, isn't just blindly evil without reasoning for it. Korsin is definitely not good, but he's not just evil-without-reasoning either. Exactly how people should be (just like a well-written good character isn't perfect all the time and struggles with their own set of morals). However, in the setting and structure that the author has put forth of how the Sith (species/org) are, I don't understand Korsin. What makes him different? How did he succeed when he doesn't have the blind bloodthirst and lust for power?
Maybe further books will explain. I'm on the 2nd one of the mini-ebook series now.
Suggested reading:
Sith (species)
While I was working on this post, a friend sent me this bit of greatness:
* My publishing credits are a piece of flash fiction in a zine, blog work, and some articles. I've got some finished novels, but I've been too shy to submit them to publishers yet.